If you want to read the most terrifying, incredibly likely theory about Harry Potter and horcruxes go NOW to SimplyKimberly and read the locked post on the matter.
Basically, what Kimberly is saying is that Harry IS one of the horcruxes. When Voldemort killed James and Lilly, he made Harry a horcrux. That would certainly explain the “traits” Harry shares with Voldemort and it sets up the gloomiest of futures for Harry. I’m so enthralled with this theory that I will support it as truth until Book 7 comes out. I think it will be proven, I really do.
I want to be WRONG! I want Ron and Hermione and Harry and Ginny to walk off into the sunset at the end of Book 7.
My other fear is that Ron will die in book 7. He has consistently been the death I have looked for since book 2. If JKR is going to stick with the whole let Harry lose everyone he cares about, then Ron would be the next logical choice. Book 7 frightens me.
I don’t mind it being true, as long as the sunset scenario plays out, too. :wink2: I can’t stand to lose Ron. I’d much rather lose, well, any other character. 😥
I never read any of the books but after you told me what went dowhe n in HBP and seeing the 3 movies I kinda thought that theory too. I always figured the last book would end with a flash forward and Harry is the Head Master of Hogwarts and his Scoobies are the other teachers. Something bad is gonna happen but my guess is the far outcome will be good.
Thats very interesting.
Hey jenn i have tuesday off, so i will call you Soon:smoke:
I don’t think Harry is a horcrux, because Dumbledore said that Voldermort couldn’t posess harry without suffering excruciating pain, and when did Voldermort have the oppurtunity to turn Harry into a horcrux, Slughorn said he had to perform some kind of spell
Hi, Dian! I think Harry’s scar is a result of a botched horcrux spell, rather than the AK curse. I know we have TONS of time to come up with new ideas, but I really think this one to be true :nod:
Crap… forgot to leave a comment earlier about this. It’s a good theory, and believable except for one thing. Didn’t DD tell Harry he has to destroy ALL the horocuxes be for he can destroy Vodlemort? If that’s so then Harry’d have to die before he killed Voldemort. Though, I could be wrong. Maybe Ron will end up saving the day. 😉
I have thought for a long time that Harry might be a horcrux, but when Voldemort tries to possess harry in book five when they are battleling in the ministry, he is unable to do it. voldemort wanted harry dead, for what reason i do not know, but i have a strong feeling it is to do with Harry’s bloodline (No one knows who the potters were related to) For harry to be a horcrux would be starnge because why does voldemort want to kill him he would be killing his own horcrux?????
Yes Dumbledore did haarry to kill al the remainding horcrux, I believe that harry will save the day and destroy all the horcrux and then kill Voldemort. The only thing i worry about is will the death of voldemort have an impact on harry? as they are connected.
Well, Dumbledore hasn’t necessarily always been right, now. Voldemort knows he has several more horcruxes and knows that the loss of the diary didn’t physically hurt him. He may think that one more lost horcrux (Harry) would be more beneficial than having it around.
Hmmm, I am still in two minds about Harry being an Horcrux, it does make alot of sense and would really explain why he is so connected to voldemort…
imagine the title of the 7th book
Harry Potter and the final Horcrux
joanna
Ok just to answer all of your questions —
1. Harry IS a horcrux and he WILL die. The series will not continue and it all makes sense. Also, last year Daniel Radcliff, the guy who actually PLAYS Harry Potter stated that he thought Harry would die in the 7th book because of all the evidence, and let’s try to think that he for one knows what he’s talking about.
2. Snape is not evil.
3. R.A.B is probably Regulus * Black (this one i’m unsure about), but it would be hard to introduce a new “hero” in the 7th book and Harry needs a parental figure and this character would be connected to Sirius — however wouldn’t Hermione have figured this one out? Hmmmm don’t take my word for this one!
Yeah, sure. Thanks, Jo. 🙄
All I can say is my heart will break if and when harry dies, what a sad life he has lived, being treated bad by muggles and constantly being hunted down by crazy wizards who want to kill him…what a sad life, there has got to be some happiness at the end for him.
I can say with 100% certainty that I don’t think Harry will die. I think he will find some peace and happiness. :wink2:
Aliza, Daniel Radcliffe thinks Harry will die, but he doesn’t know that for sure as it’s not him that writes the book. JK Rowling keeps the plot of her books secret, even to her family. Everyone says he will die, but everyone didn’t asume that dumbledore would die how he did.Or that RAB (in my opinion Regulas Alphus (i think) Black. Alphus i think was the name of their uncle, so i am asuming that was what the A stood for.It will be wonderul if he was till alive and he protects harry…Harry eventually goes to live in the wizarding world
regulas cant still be alive because the house has passed to harry and it wouldnt have if a remaining black brother was still here, ps, his uncle was alphard 🙂
Oh, I agree re: Regulus, but I think it was he who took the horcrux quite a while ago, before his death. :wink2:
I totally forgot about the Will…ok so Regulas is dead and i read an interview where JK said that there will be no more new characters. Clearly Regulas stole the locket before he died and left the note with the fake one…….Harry even though he doesnt want to go back to Grimmauld place he has to, to try and find the locket…..Or ask Kreacher or Mundungus, because i bet either one of those two will know of its whereabouts.
Oh my just thought of something, who would Voldemort have killed for that hORCRUX TO BE CREATED?
JOANNA
i acually think its really funny that people think harry is a horcrux. ovbiously you need to re-read the 6th book and how to make a horcrux.
why would lord voldemort make harry a horcrux if he’s bent on killing him. and if it was an accidental horcrux (which i dont think would happen) then it would be harry’s scar, not harry himself. honestly people, your just as bad as the harry/hermione shippers. i could understand if you just thought this theory was possible, but its the people who think this is the only correct theory that annoy me. lets keep in mind that none of you are J.K. Rowling, so stop arguing over somthing no one really knows that answer to
Harry is definetly not a Horcrux.. Honestly where do you people come up with this stuff. He can’t kill himself. Look if Harry was a horcrux than that means Voldemort intentionally put some of himself in Harry which he didn’t. So no. No soul part of Voldemort is in him. Just some of his powers. Remember just because you did a horcrux doesn’t mean you lose powers. You keep them you just lose part/half of your soul. Why can’t you people read that and remember it? Honestly. These stupid rumors are so annoying. None of them are true.
First of all, this is a personal website. It is not a forum. Take your “Honestly… *le sigh*” and Harmony crap elsewhere. Thanks.
yes very true Sarah i will re read the book again….Excuse me Jenn I am sorry, but isnt this topic about harry potter? And did you not start the topic of conversation. I am sorry for treating your personal site as a forum and will take my
Harry potter Hocrux converatsion else where.
Joanna, your comments have been insightful and polite. The last two comments were neither. I didn’t think the post would get much attention, but your contribution has been wonderful! 😉
I have jumped the gun a bit to fast sorry about that.Now that i know that the message wasn’t meant for me i will definately continue the conversation on your site as i think it is very good………
joanna
I think that Regulus is the one who left the note and that the horcrux is actually hidden away at the Black mansion. That is unless Mundagus hasn’t already raided it from there. Remember when they found a locket that wouldn’t open and Sirius said that it might have been his mother’s who had put several different enchaments on her possesions? wouldn’t that be the Slytherian locket that Voldermort took? It would make perfect sense that it was the locket and Regulus because he tried to get out, and was really close to the main circle of Voldemorts followers and Voldemort personally killed him. And didn’t they say that he had others kill for him? That nobody was that important to be killed by him personaly. So it would make senese that he killed Regulus personaly because he took and hid a horcrux from him. So I think that the locket is at the Black mansion which now belongs to Harry, ironic, since Harry never wants to step foot in there ever again. Also that Regulus is the one who left the note, that way it’s a way to redem himself from what he has done. that’s what I think ~sorry if I rambled~
Wow! I can’t wait to re-read OoTP to get the details on the locket. I really like your theories, Courtney and I think they are valid. :wink2:
I was rereading it too and i messed something up. Voldemort didn’t kill Regulus personally but had someone do it for him. The locket it mentioned briefly onpage 116 in the American version. I was so happy to find this because it proves some of my theroy, well at least I hope so. thank jenn for the comment
i would lyk 2 c Harry show off sum kool power in front of the Dursleys after his 17th bday,coz that means he could use magic outside of skool. i dont think that Harry will die but some ppl who are realy close 2 him will hav 2 b sacrificed..:cry:. i think that Harry will become Headmaster of Hogwarts and sum of his friends wil b teachers there 2. I jus hope the ending wont be too depressing or emotional or pathetic(but i doubt that).
JK Rowling has already posted that Harry, Hermione, and Ron will survive the 7th book. I think that one of the Weasley’s will die, but I’m not sure if that will happen since Bill was attacked by a werewolf. I know I don’t want Remus Lupin to die, he’s the last Maraduer:cry:, besides Peter, but I don’t care about him. I was surprised to find out that Harry now holds a small bit of pity for Draco. but then again who couldn’t now that he did show that he defied Voldemorts orders to kill Dumbledore:cry: I think he’ll have a better part in the next one, i hope.
oh that has made me very happy to hear that JK Rowling says he will not die, but i think that someone very close will be sacrificed probably Remus Lupin. He and Peter Pettigrew are the last remaning Marauders I believe Peter will die at the hands of Voldemort and that Lupin will die in battle trying to save harry.
yes courtney, I also hope that Draco plays more of a role in the last book…I am sure that his parents will not survive, but it seems that harry is concerned for him and will protect him.
joanna
courtney what you said about the locket and regulas was exactly what i said on another group, well not exactly but near enough what you wrote and i had so many other hp fans telling me they thought i was wrong, I am glad you could see that the horcrux is the same locket that was in the blacks house…I only hope that JK Rowling really explains about it in the 7th book…..oh speaking of the book, i heard that it will be shorter than the 6th book…..rumour of course, but i wouldnt like to think it might be true…the book needs to be at least 800 pages or more to keep me happy…lol
ml
joanna
Two things:
1) I made the same assertion on my blog after reading the sixth book.
http://www.mostlymuppet.com/archives/2005/07/24/harry-potter-horcrux/
2) My wife’s name is Jenn Miller and we looked in to purchasing jennmiller.com a while ago. Glad to finally have a reason to comment.
joanna I totally agree with u that the 7th book should be the longest, since it’s the last installment:cry:. I mean she has so much that she needs to write about. I’m glad to hear that there are other people who also believe that the locket is at the black mansion. I know that there are a lot of people who don’t think this is true but we’ll prove them wrong in the end! ( I Hope) Someone I know spoiled the 6th book for me before I got to read it. But then again I spoiled my self when I was looking at the Chapter names and saw that one line that ruins everyhting, and tells who dies. I was so angry at myself. Well the person who spoiled it for me I spoiled it for him because he acted and sounded like he had akready read it and so when I said who killed who. He was shocked then read the book in two days and spoiled it for me a little. He’s the one that told me about R.A.B. so I had a while to figure it out. and it was when I read Regulus’ name in the 5th book that it clicked for me but I didn’t know how he was going to help since he is already dead. But then JK said that their will be NO new Characters intoduced from then on sooo. I think it’ll be Regulus. Lets all hope and pray!:nod:
Oh I am sure we and many others around the world will prove those who don’t think the locket is the horcrux wrong…I will laugh in a certain persons face..Actually I think i will put a little cash on it, just between myself and her…I am confident i will win…lol
As for people spoiling the book for others i had to leave a group because the mod was letting people ruin the book for others i got so fed up that I started to type all kinds of abuse at these annoying people (adult hp group, so i wasn’t swearing at kids) I don’t usually lose my temper, but when people keep spoiling the books, it gets me cheesed off:cussing:….I’m in my 20’s and have 2 kids, but when it comes to HP you would not believe me….. 🙂
ml
joanna
Hi, Seth! Good theory you have. I have no idea how this is going to wrap up, but I think that’s the right idea. :nod: Let your wife know that she has an AWESOME name. 😉
I hope you gals are correct about the locket. That will be gold. I had to try so hard not to spoil anyone, but my friends in Brazil caved and bought the English language book just because they couldn’t stand the wait, so I kind of succeeded.
Can I correct a couple of incorrect statements in this thread,
1. JKR -NEVER- said that Harry, Hermione and Ron will survive book 7. She did say that one of Harry’s close friends will become a teacher at Hogwarts (it’s not who you think it is … but it’s not Ron?!?!?).
2. JKR NEVER said how long book 7 will be …. but she did say the last word is currently set to “scar.”. She said she’s not sure how long the last book will be – but she thinks it might be shorter than OOTP.
In terms of theories, I don’t believe you can discount Harry as a Horcrux yet. The spell was not cast at Harry .. he was in the cot and did not see his mother die … Isn’t it possible he was preparing a Horcrux during the murder of Lilly – but because he died, the Horcrux bounded onto Harry?? I believe this is still a plausible theory …. however, other clues (eg. Harry must destroy all of the horcruxes before he can kill Voldemort) do add doubt.
Yes i heard that the last word will be scar. I have been wondering what the ending will be “But Harry Potter would always be remembered for his scar” ,
“He was a normal teeanger, he no longer had his cursed scar”
2 years is too long to wait, but in the mean time i am reading some very interesting FF’s to keep me going.
Oh and i thought that harry was a horcrux, but when i realised that Harry must Kill voldemort i thought maybe he can’t be a horcrux, because he would have to kill himself first, but then who would kill Voldemort….Unless he kills Voldemort and then kills himself????? oh either the outcome the book is going to be so sad….I have a strong feeling that Neville will be the close friend to become the professor and sadly i have a strong feeling one of the Weasley’s will die and so will many others including Lupin
ml
joanna